Game innovation.
We went for dinner with a cousin of mine last night and he was half-bitching about how there’s been no “really new” games out recently (specifically for the PC since that’s what he has). At first I didn’t think much about it, but later I did put more consideration into the issue.
Don’t get me wrong - I’m not saying that new games suck. I happen to enjoy most of my last few years of purchases, but he’s right - none of them are new or innovative. Everything seems to be pretty evolutionary instead of revolutionary. Like even looking at the last few games we’ve bought:
- Guitar Hero - great, but totally derivative of every other beat- and music-game before it. It’s really really good though, but doesn’t really bring anything actually new to the table.
- Battlefield 2, Metal Gear Solid 3, Half Life 2, Civilization 4, Resident Evil 4, Gran Turismo 4, The Elder Scrolls 4 - anything with a number after it is almost always by definition not innovative. Granted I loved the shit out of most of these games (and I still play Battlefield quite a bit).
- Prey - now I just got this, but I’ve played the demo. It’s a hell of a lot of fun, but again nothing new. The lone badass in some s.f. environment killing aliens is a very old formula. The engine has neat “portal” technology so it does get points for that.
- Titan Quest - I’m enjoying this one, but Blizzard would probably win if they sued these guys for plagiarism. I’m only half serious.
- God of War - another PS2 one from last year. Really good action game, but beat-em-ups have been around forever.
So what recently have I played that’s fresh and innovative? Katamari Damacy comes immediately to mind (of course). Then the creators followed it up immediately with two sequels that while enjoyable added very little to the main idea.
There’s at least Spore in the future that’s pretty innovative. And the Nintendo DS has some games that are - off the top of my head I’d say Phoenix Wright and Trauma Center. And I’m not pining away for innovation and claiming things suck. I’m just wondering where it is right now.
Anyone have suggestions for games that are innovative and fun? Not just one or the other :-)






